Informe sobre expediente de relevancia jurídica sobre la sentencia Nº03383-2021-PA/TC, E-2864. Del reconocimiento formal a la justicia hídrica: estudio crítico del Caso Punchana (Sentencia 322/2023, Expediente N.° 03383-2021-PA/TC) y la deuda estructural del Tribunal Constitucional peruano en materia de derecho fundamental al agua potable
Fecha
Autores
Título de la revista
ISSN de la revista
Título del volumen
Editor
Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú
Acceso al texto completo solo para la Comunidad PUCP
Resumen
El presente informe analiza el caso Punchana, tramitado bajo el Expediente N.°
03383-2021-PA/TC y resuelto por el Tribunal Constitucional mediante sentencia del 11 de agosto
de 2023, posteriormente supervisada por auto del 27 de junio de 2024. La controversia involucra
a los asentamientos humanos Iván Vásquez Valera y 21 de Setiembre, en el distrito de Punchana,
Loreto, cuya población vive desde hace más de dos décadas sin acceso a redes públicas de agua
potable ni de alcantarillado.
El estudio sostiene una tesis crítica con dos hojas. En el plano dogmático, el Tribunal definió con
solvencia el contenido constitucionalmente protegido del derecho fundamental al agua potable,
sistematizó sus tres componentes esenciales —acceso, calidad y suficiencia— e integró el
estándar internacional del Comité de Derechos Económicos, Sociales y Culturales. Este
reconocimiento consolida la línea jurisprudencial peruana iniciada en los Expedientes N.°
06534-2006-AA/TC y N.° 00012-2019-PI/TC, y articula el artículo 7-A de la Constitución
incorporado por la Ley N.° 30588 de 2017. En el plano estructural, en cambio, el Tribunal no
diseñó un remedio ejecutable, el auto de supervisión documenta que ninguna de las entidades
requeridas reconoció responsabilidad estructural y que la situación material en los asentamientos
demandantes no varió en lo sustancial.
El informe lee esta asimetría desde cuatro categorías articuladas —constitucionalismo
transformador, constitucionalismo ecológico, justicia hídrica y desigualdad territorial— y desde
la jurisprudencia comparada que ha desarrollado modelos más densos de tutela estructural. La
distancia entre el reconocimiento formal del derecho al agua potable y la justicia hídrica
entendida en sentido fuerte —distribución equitativa, reconocimiento de derechos colectivos,
participación de las comunidades en la gestión— es la deuda que el caso Punchana revela y que
este estudio se propone nombrar con precisión.
This report analyzes the Punchana case, processed under File No. 03383-2021-PA/TC and resolved by the Peruvian Constitutional Court through its judgment of August 11, 2023, subsequently supervised by the resolution of June 27, 2024. The controversy involves the human settlements Iván Vásquez Valera and 21 de Setiembre, in the Punchana district, Loreto region, whose population has lived for more than two decades without access to public drinking water or sewage networks. The study advances a critical thesis with two sides. At the doctrinal level, the Court soundly defined the constitutionally protected content of the fundamental right to drinking water, systematized its three essential components —access, quality, and sufficiency— and incorporated the international standard developed by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. This recognition consolidates the Peruvian jurisprudential line initiated in Files No. 06534-2006-AA/TC and No. 00012-2019-PI/TC and articulates Article 7-A of the Constitution introduced by Law No. 30588 of 2017. At the structural level, however, the Court did not design an enforceable remedy, the supervision resolution documents that none of the required entities acknowledged structural responsibility and that the material situation in the demanding settlements did not substantively change. The report reads this asymmetry through four articulated categories —transformative constitutionalism, ecological constitutionalism, water justice, and territorial inequality— and against the comparative jurisprudence that has developed denser models of structural protection. The distance between the formal recognition of the right to drinking water and water justice understood in a strong sense —equitable distribution, recognition of collective rights, community participation in management— is the debt that the Punchana case reveals and that this study seeks to name with precision.
This report analyzes the Punchana case, processed under File No. 03383-2021-PA/TC and resolved by the Peruvian Constitutional Court through its judgment of August 11, 2023, subsequently supervised by the resolution of June 27, 2024. The controversy involves the human settlements Iván Vásquez Valera and 21 de Setiembre, in the Punchana district, Loreto region, whose population has lived for more than two decades without access to public drinking water or sewage networks. The study advances a critical thesis with two sides. At the doctrinal level, the Court soundly defined the constitutionally protected content of the fundamental right to drinking water, systematized its three essential components —access, quality, and sufficiency— and incorporated the international standard developed by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. This recognition consolidates the Peruvian jurisprudential line initiated in Files No. 06534-2006-AA/TC and No. 00012-2019-PI/TC and articulates Article 7-A of the Constitution introduced by Law No. 30588 of 2017. At the structural level, however, the Court did not design an enforceable remedy, the supervision resolution documents that none of the required entities acknowledged structural responsibility and that the material situation in the demanding settlements did not substantively change. The report reads this asymmetry through four articulated categories —transformative constitutionalism, ecological constitutionalism, water justice, and territorial inequality— and against the comparative jurisprudence that has developed denser models of structural protection. The distance between the formal recognition of the right to drinking water and water justice understood in a strong sense —equitable distribution, recognition of collective rights, community participation in management— is the debt that the Punchana case reveals and that this study seeks to name with precision.
Descripción
Palabras clave
Perú. Tribunal Constitucional--Jurisprudencia, Agua--Legislación--Perú, Servicios públicos--Perú, Recursos hidráulicos--Perú--Loreto, Derecho de aguas--Legislación--Perú
Citación
Colecciones
item.page.endorsement
item.page.review
item.page.supplemented
item.page.referenced
Licencia Creative Commons
Excepto donde se indique lo contrario, la licencia de este ítem se describe como http://purl.org/coar/access_right/c_abf2
